2016 Player Star Ratings

For the third consecutive season we have measured up every WSEM player and rated them on a scale of 1-5 stars (including half increments). The measure used to evaluate the offensive production of a player is Adjusted Weighted On-Base Average (Adjusted wOBA); the specific adjustment to the wOBA equation being the devaluation of walks (BB) from the MLB iteration. Every player bats, therefore every player receives an offensive rating.

Adjusted wOBA = ((0.2605 * BB) + (0.89 * 1B) + (1.27 * 2B) + (1.62 * 3B) + (2.1 * HR)) / PA
Value as a pitcher comes down to a balance of two things: dominance and consistency. Strike Outs per Inning Pitched (KPI) is used to put a number on the "dominance" of a pitcher's stuff. The familiar stat of Walks and Hits per Inning Pitched (WHIP) is then used to quantify how consistently they perform. Subtract WHIP from KPI and we can see how the pitchers measure up against each other.

KPI - WHIP (Strike Outs per Inning Pitched - Walks and Hits per Inning Pitched)
Note: A negative KPI - WHIP value is not a negative assessment of the pitcher; this stat only provides a scale to compare against other pitchers. Furthermore, pitching can never decrease a player's rating; ability to pitch - if only in a serviceable capacity - can only add to a player's value.

Other considerations affecting a player rating:
  • Added value from outstanding defensive ability
  • Lesser value for limited playing time or dedication
  • Career performance and pedigree
A one-week period will be granted for arbitration of player ratings. All arbitration requests must be filed using the form found at this link. Requests must be submitted by noon EDT on Tuesday, 9/8/2015.

Remember, star ratings only directly impact the dollar value against the salary cap for captains and franchised players. The star ratings for all players entering the draft basicaly serve as an early assessment of their market value. Captains have until October 1st to franchise players on their current roster; each team may use up to two franchise tags, but every team must franchise at least one player in addition to the captain.
PLAYER ADJUSTED wOBA KPI - WHIP OA RATING
 Evan Bortmas .393 5
 Craig Skinner .328 1.52 5
 Evan Bischoff .312 2.13 5
 Stephen Farkas .292 2.32 5
 Austin Bischoff .296 ('14) 1.87 ('14) 5
 Dennis Pearson .345 -.57 4.5
 Travis Strojny .284 1.40 4.5
 Scott Kujawa .239 1.50 4.5
 Trey Jardine .219 1.70 4.5
 Chandler Phillips .290 1.20 4.5
 David Castle .301 .51 4.5
 Stephen Werner .356 4
 Greg Brannan .350 4
 Sam Hatt .248 1.32 4
 Brandon D'Agnese .337 0.86 4
 Andrew Bruen .342 1.21 4
 Joel Crozier .329 1.16 4
 Nate Gendron .308 1.09 4
 Nicco Lollio .274 0.91 4
 Kevin Doby .248 .83 3.5
 RJ Fisher .196 1.38 3.5
 Michael Giguere .302 3.5
 Michael Spence .301 0.00 3.5
 Mike D'Agnese .298 3.5
 Kyle Tomlinson .296 3.5
 Jeff Bencher .297 3
 Dylan Braden .270 3
 Josh Nagorski .264 3
 Brandon Corbett .264 3
 Raymond Brown .205 0.47 3
 Nick Braden .173 0.33 3
 Mike Bayley .239 3
 Kiefer Haffey .141 0.48 3
 Michael Villarreal .238 2.5
 John Sharlow .236 2.5
 Jason Hewlett .234 -0.55 2.5
 Alex Linebrink .234 2.5
 Justin Chandler .256 2.5
 Dash Fejza .219 -0.11 2.5
 Carl Coffee .233 2
 Nathan Rutkowski .221 2
 Dakota LaDouceur .208 2
 Nate Bellinger .201 2
 Mark Phillips .198 2
 Chris Paquin .188 -0.17 2
 Zac Adams .187 -0.04 2
 Michael Maystead .190 1.5
 Mike Myers .186 1.5
 Mark Brannan .182 1.5
 John McKinnie .176 1.5
 Alex Shore .175 1.5
 Jason Hollister .169 1.5
 Damien Rogers .161 1.5
 Nate Motta .131 1
 Michael Sessions .192 1
 Ryan Alexia .124 1
 David Buhr .122 1
 Alexis Dionne .086 1

WSEM League Stats — Season by Season Comparison

SEASON AVG %change OBP %change SLG %change
2015:  .205 -3.15 .376 +1.99 .364 -6.45
2014:  .211 -19.78 .369 -23.24 .389 -14.60
2013:  .263 +16.41 .481 +33.47 .455 +28.85
2012:  .226 -19.55 .360 -18.16 .353 -13.24
2011:  .281 -- .440 -- .407 --
The first thing that is likely to jump out when looking at the above table is how the league batted just over the Mendoza line in 2015. The second thing is probably how there's a lot more red than green - twice as much, as a matter of fact. Something that probably doesn't creep out until after a couple longer looks is how small the 2015 year-over-year percentage changes are compared to previous seasons. Is that a sign that the league is finding its level?

Let's break it down by the circumstances of each season:

2011: "The Beta Test" -- WSEM's first full season. Dennis Pearson was the only pitcher who'd be in a category comparable with today's aces, until Austin Bischoff showed up to throw 4 games at the end of the season. Most pitchers were just learning the game. A few of the better arms might be serviceable number-twos now, but in just about every case facing pitchers in 2011 was a much friendlier environment.

2012: "The Year of the Pitcher" -- The pitching rotation rule was added in the hope of establishing greater pitching depth. Apparently pitching gained more than just depth. 8 perfect games were thrown in 2012; that's almost 40% of the total PG's in WSEM history.

2013: "The Anomaly" -- Needing to boost offensive production black bats were introduced and the mound was moved back three feet: to 48 feet from the board.

2014: "Welcome to the Modern ERA" -- Second year with the new rules and the honeymoon is over. The primary offensive stat categories all dropped off as sharply as they rose, returning to similar numbers from 2012.

2015: "So This is Real Life?" -- At a decrease of 35 points slugging percentage was really the only significant change. One went slightly up, the other slightly down, but both batting average and on-base percentage stayed fairly consistent. Also worth noting… 2015 is the first season that didn't see all three numbers break in the same direction.

All in all league-wide AVG, OBP and SLG are quite comparable across the three seasons that don't present obvious reasons for higher output: 2012, 2014, and 2015. The variance in AVG over these three years is just .021; OBP just .016; and SLG .036. That is pretty steady. Not necessarily pretty… yet nonetheless steady.

The main reason for throwing up this article was that it'd be fun to look back at the ups and downs of where we've been. An added bonus is that it grants the opportunity to bring up what will likely be the most significant change coming to WSEM in 2016 to address the not so pretty numbers: the size of our strike zone.

Ever since 2005, when Carl got the measurements from Alan Garcia (Wifflehouse, Garcia Division namesake), we've used a board measuring 30" tall by 22" wide. Eleven years later we'll be shaving off two inches in one direction, the other, or both. The idea here is that this will allow the batter to focus on defending a smaller area - essentially decreasing his chances of being wrong in the guessing game. The overall strike zone area could decrease by anywhere from 46 square inches to 100 square inches depending on which of the three proposals is chosen. The new dimensions will be decided by a captains' vote later this offseason.

There are likely a couple questions dancing around in your heads, so let's jump into FAQ mode:

Q: Isn’t this just asking to increase walks?
A: Not at all. While walks will probably see a slight increase due to losing old corners, the idea here is that batters will have less area to focus on protecting. Concentrating on a smaller area will actually increase balls put in play. Also worth noting: The majority of strikes thrown hit off the face of the board; the only strikes we’ll be losing by cropping off an inch per side are those that grazed or clipped the outside corners.

Q: What about introducing loco/screwball/GTSOH bats to improve contact?
A: The bigger barrels and extra length would definitely improve hitting. However, not only do these bats improve contact, they also add 20+ feet of distance to hits. We’d have to retool and find a way to lengthen pretty much every field we play on in order to keep games playable. We’re not going to do that, and we’re not going to introduce the bigger bats.

Q: Will there also be a set height off the ground for the board to rest?
A: Yes. Captains will also vote to set a standard height off the ground for the bottom of the board at either 10" or 12".


Retired 2011-2015 K-zone

Prop 1: 28" x 22" K-zone

Prop 2: 30" x 20" K-zone

Prop 3: 28" x 20" K-zone

2015 Handies

BATTING CHAMPION COUNTRY STRONG HR KING
EVAN BORTMAS .365
STEPHEN WERNER .304
DENNIS PEARSON .272
EVAN BISCHOFF .270
GREG BRANNAN .265
GREG BRANNAN 14
DAVID CASTLE 13
DENNIS PEARSON 13
CHANDLER PHILLIPS 12
BORTMAS, B. D'AGNESE 10
GREAT LAKES STEALER WALKER TEXAS RANGER
DYLAN BRADEN 13
CHRIS PAQUIN 12
EVAN BORTMAS 10
STEPHEN FARKAS 10
BRANDON D'AGNESE 8
CHRIS PAQUIN 64
EVAN BORTMAS 54
KYLE TOMLINSON 43
ALEX SHORE 39
MARK BRANNAN 37
MOST VALUABLE PLAYER
EVAN BORTMAS 30 pts
6 #1 VOTES
AVG:  .365
OBP:  .545
SLG:  .672
HR:  10
RBI:  48
RS:  48
PA/RBI:  3.98
STEPHEN WERNER 16 pts
0 #1 VOTES
GREG BRANNAN 12 pts
0 #1 VOTES
EVAN BISCHOFF 4 pts
0 #1 VOTES
DENNIS PEARSON 4 pts
0 #1 VOTES
CLOWN SHU
STEPHEN FARKAS 29 pts
5 #1 VOTES
ERA:  0.32
WHIP:  0.42
K:  253
K/6:  16.4
K/BB:  11.0
CS%:  3/3
IP:  92.1
EVAN BISCHOFF 19 pts
0 #1 VOTES
SCOTT KUJAWA 12 pts
1 #1 VOTE
CRAIG SKINNER 11 pts
0 #1 VOTES
TRAVIS STROJNY 8 pts
0 #1 VOTES
ROOKIE OF THE YEAR
SCOTT KUJAWA 30 pts
6 #1 VOTES
ERA:  0.82
WHIP:  1.00
K/6:  15.0
K/BB:  3.8
OPS:  .694
HR:  6
RBI:  18
NATE GENDRON 16 pts
0 #1 VOTES
MICHAEL GIGUERE 15 pts
0 #1 VOTES
RAYMOND BROWN 10 pts
0 #1 VOTES
DASH FEJZA 8 pts
0 #1 VOTES
MOST IMPROVED PLAYER
TRAVIS STROJNY 20 pts
4 #1 VOTES
ERA:  1.37
WHIP:  0.93
K/6:  14.0
AVG:  .241
OPS:  .694
HR:  7
PA/RBI:  6.0
EVAN BISCHOFF 16 pts
0 #1 VOTES
JOHN SHARLOW 9 pts
0 #1 VOTES
MICHAEL VILLARREAL 5 pts
1 #1 VOTE
BAYLEY, M. D'AGNESE 4 pts
0 #1 VOTES
DIAMOND DIGITS  -  OUTFIELD

MIKE BAYLEY 26 pts
3 #1 VOTES

GREG BRANNAN 21 pts
1 #1 VOTE
DIAMOND DIGIT  -  SS DIAMOND DIGIT  -  P

EVAN BORTMAS 24 pts
4 #1 VOTES

JASON HEWLETT 17 pts
3 #1 VOTES

Checking in on the WSEM 100-Hit Club

WSEM 100-Hit Club
# PLAYER H
1  Dennis Pearson 198
2  Kyle Tomlinson 169
3  David Castle 163
4  Dylan Braden 160
5  Evan Bortmas 158
6  Brandon Corbett 138
7  Alex Shore 133
8  Chandler Phillips 128
9  Josh Nagorski 117
10  Craig Skinner 109
11  Evan Bischoff 108
12  Alex Linebrink 108
13  Nick Braden 104
14  Austin Bischoff 100
100-Hit Watch List
PLAYER H
 Mark Brannan 99
 Greg Brannan 97
 Dakota LaDouceur 96
 Carl Coffee 93
 Joel Crozier 90
 Sam Hatt 80
 Stephen Farkas 76
 Stephen Werner 71
The Brannan twins are all but guaranteed to reach the 100-hit threshold next season. The fun thing to watch with these two could be pitting brother against brother to see who crosses the line first.

LaDouceur, Coffee, Crozier, and Hatt are right on the doorstep. We can't call them locks to get in, though, because of one thing: uncertain playing time.

LaDouceur's playing time nearly evaporated in 2015. He played just 8 games, adding 5 hits to his career total. If repeated that number would be enough, but his last game was June 20. Will he be back?

Coffee's been happy to take on a manager-first role the past two years, keeping him from already surpassing the 100 H mark. Making his chance a long shot in 2016 isn't his stick, he had 8 H in under half a season played (61 PA) in 2013, rather the question of whether Carl will be back with us next year.

Crozier racked up 5 hits in just 2 games in 2015 while living in Boston. His summer 2016 plans are up in the air, but if he can fit just a few weeks of WSEM into his schedule he'll shoot past 100 with ease.

Since beginning his career with 45 H in 2012, Hatt has played part time ever since. Living in Chicago will have that effect. 20 H could be a steep challenge; Sam hasn't bested 15 H in any of the last 3 seasons.

Farkas and Werner are the last two names on this list, but they aren't long shots to make the 100-hit club in 2016. Both are only two seasons in and average over 35 hits per. Barring anything keeping them from a full-season, go ahead and call this easy money.

Championship Series Results: Games 3-5 - Poolside Park

 2015 Scoresheet (.PDF) ‣  League Lineup Stats Entry
WSEM Championship:  Best of 5 Series          Saturday,  August 15          1 PM
GAME 3
2 1
 WP: Hatt (2-0)
 
 LP: Haffey (0-1)
 HR: Kujawa (1)
GAME 4
0 1
 LP: Gendron (1-1)
 
 WP: Kujawa (3-0)
 
GAME 5
2 1
 WP: E. Bischoff (2-1)
 Bortmas (2)
 LP: Jardine (1-3)
 
TOP 2
AVG
BORTMAS .365
E. BISCHOFF .270
OPS
BORTMAS 1.216
GENDRON .941
RBI
BORTMAS 48
E. BISCHOFF 35
ERA
E. BISCHOFF 0.48
GENDRON 1.09
WHIP
E. BISCHOFF 0.53
HATT 1.08
K/6
E. BISCHOFF 16.0
HATT 14.4
Series Tied  1 - 1
Men of the 'Ship (so far):
1.  Scott Kujawa:  Perfect game thrown in Game 1
2.  Nate Gendron:  Game-winning, series-tying solo HR in Game 2
3.  Stephen Werner:  Set pace with solo HR in Bot 2 of Game 1
Looking Ahead:
-  Jardine and Bischoff ineligible to pitch for 2 games
-  #3 pitchers will play a pivotal role
-  1st time any member of Red Cox has played at Poolside Park
Watch Games 1 & 2 Highlights:
TOP 2
AVG
WERNER .304
BELLINGER .198
OPS
WERNER .999
KUJAWA .693
RBI
WERNER 23
KUJAWA 18
ERA
JARDINE 0.58
KUJAWA 0.82
WHIP
JARDINE 0.96
HAFFEY 0.96
K/6
JARDINE 16.0
KUJAWA 15.0

All-Star Game & HR Derby Results - Coffee Grounds

 2015 Scoresheet (.PDF) ‣  League Lineup Stats Entry
Home Run Derby          Saturday,  August 8          4 PM
1ST ROUND  -  3 minutes to hit as many HR as possible

C. Phillips
20
Strojny
22
Pearson
25
G. Brannan
20
Castle
18
FINAL ROUND  -  Top 2 from 1st Round go head-to-head, swinging with 10 outs
TRAVIS STROJNY:
19
DENNIS PEARSON:
10


All-Star Game          Saturday,  August 8          5 PM
★ ★  GARCIA  ★ ★ ★ ★  RINGLER  ★ ★
8 5
 WP: Strojny
 HR: Castle (1,2), Farkas (1), G. Brannan (1)
 LP: E. Bischoff
 HR: Villarreal (1,2), Adams (1)
ALL-STAR GAME WINS
2

REG. SEASON WINS
85
SP: Stephen Farkas
RP: Chandler Phillips
RP: Travis Strojny
LF: Greg Brannan
RF: Kyle Tomlinson
SS: David Castle
SP: Evan Bischoff
RP: Trey Jardone
RP: Scott Kujawa
LF: Evan Bortmas
RF: Stephen Werner
SS: Zac Adams
ALL-STAR GAME WINS
2

REG. SEASON WINS
160

Championship Series Results: Games 1 & 2 - Coffee Grounds

 2015 Scoresheet (.PDF) ‣  League Lineup Stats Entry
WSEM Championship:  Best of 5 Series          Saturday,  August 8          1 PM
GAME 1
0 2
 LP: E. Bischoff (0-1)
 
 WP: Kujawa (2-0)
 HR: Werner (1)
GAME 2
1 0
 WP: E. Bischoff (1-1)
 HR: Gendron (1)
 LP: Jardine (1-2)
 
AVG:  .249
SLG:  .453
RpG:  5.8
ERA:  1.98
WHIP:  1.12
K/6:  13.9
Season Series Numbers
W RS H HR BB AVG SLG OBP
WA 2 7 12 1 17 .150 .200 .299
RC 2 12 22 6 14 .250 .466 .353
AVG:  .193
SLG:  .336
RpG:  1.9
ERA:  1.84
WHIP:  1.14
K/6:  14.5